Are you focusing on only half of the investment picture?
Many of our clients work with more than one money manager. Each manager may bring a specialty and focus to a particular area of their portfolio. Our focus is two fold. First we concentrate on protecting gains during corrections. But we also focus on capturing the bulk or more of the upward moves, in between those bear markets. It is important to focus on a meaningful time frame when evaluating any money manager. It needs to be sufficient enough to accurately provide some evidence that the manager can deliver the specialty that you are seeking. In the field of science, one of the most valuable assets a scientist has is a rich and diverse sample set. Their research peers will very quickly notice the inherent errors in judgement that can occur by using what they refer to as a "statistically insignificant sample size".
We all can get excited when the markets do well. Lets take the first 8 1/2 months of 2019. The broad US stock market has gone up in all but two months. In fact during this limited time period, it has probably outperformed many investment approaches. The graph below shows the performance of the S&P 500® Index from 12/31/18 to 9/20/19.
But wasn't the market due for some type of run up? Are some of the markets gains in 2019 because of how bad it did in 2018? What happens when you step back and widen your focus, looking at a more meaningful time frame? The graph below also shows the performance of the S&P 500® Index, but this time we pull back and include the market high on September 20, 2018.
Now more data points start to give you a better picture of the kind of ride the market had during these 12 months. Do you feel the industry forces you into believing this kind of ride is necessary in order to match or exceed the market returns?
The final graph below shows the Index performance against some of the Porter Investment Strategies for the same one year period, taken from actual tracking account values. When done correctly, smoother rides do not always mean inferior returns.
The only time it is important to capture every single upward move in the market, like in 2019, is when someone did not have the discipline to protect their prior gains when the market corrected, as it did in 2018.
We all strive for market beating returns, but evaluate your investment approaches using meaningful time frames and ask yourself, "What kind of ride do I want?"
Think a recession or the next bear market is just around the corner? Schedule a brief 30 minute visit with us or call 713-461-5303.